Wednesday, August 10, 2011

COMPARISON: Physicians Formula Baked Trio vs. WnW Walking On Eggshells

A few days ago while doing an EOTD (last image) with my new Physicans Formula Baked Wet/Dry Eyeshadow Trio in Baked Sugar (given to me by Holly Ann) i noticed it was eerily similar to Wet N Wild's Walking On Eggshells Trio which i purchased several months ago for myself. So i decided to do some swatch comparisons for you :)
Swatches L to R
second image
    P.F. Baked Sugar pearly white shade (#1) Wet N Wild Walking On Eggshells browbone shade (#1) P.F. Baked Sugar champagne shade (#2) Wet N Wild Walking On Eggshells eyelid shade (#2) P.F. Baked Sugar light brown shade (#3) Wet N Wild Walking On Eggshells crease shade (#3)
I hope my swatches are easy enough to understand. I put the swatches next to eachother to show how similar they are. The only real differences i see between these two palettes is the brown - which is darker on the WnW palette. Otherwise the shades are pretty similar as are the finishes and quality.
The last image is an EOTD i created today with the P.F. Baked Sugar
Wet/Dry Trio. I used the champagne shade on the lid, brown shade in the crease, and white shade on the browbone as a highlight. I finished the look with brown eyeliner on my waterlines and 1 coat of brown mascara on my top lashes only. It was simple and pretty for a lazy day at home w/ just a little grocery shopping to do.
Both palettes are great quality although there is a large price difference, being that the Physicans Formula trio is much more expensive than the Wet N Wild trio. However i love them both. What do you think of these? Are the shades close enough to be dupes? Thanks for reading :)


  1. Looks very similar but it's obvious that the two aren't the same! But I really like both of them (:

  2. Thanks for the comparison! They do look very similar, but I love that WnW is more pigmented and costs less than PF! I wasn't wholly impressed with my PF trio either. Not as pigmented as I would have hoped, dry OR wet :/